I'm not big on 6" mic toe boots, so my everyday boots ( non work, because they're not black ) are Thorogood 8364 8" plain toe.
The moc toe looks nice but it's just not my preference, and I love the added support of an 8".
The tumble relaxed Horween leather they use is known to not quite have as many years in it as redwings stiffer S&B leather, but it has almost no break in period and their " max wear " urethane wedge sole is longer lasting.
If you could get them resoled with the Max wear wedge it would balance out, but since you'll have to get a standard Christy wedge in the end you may get one less resole out of them over a redwing.
I think for my next pair of work boots I'll look for a black thorogood in a wedge sole, I like my Justin's but the heeled sole is not as comfortable for walking on hard ground all day.
I've heard if you get a good more custom boot from one of the PNW makers like whites, Nick's, or wesco which will have a higher arch that it's much less of an issue but I can't afford a $500-$600 pair of boots.
$300 is really my max.