I normally don't like smooth, polished, ergonomic ratchets. Once my hands get even a little greasy it's difficult to hold on to them. Especially the smaller 1/4"ers.
That being said, both of these are very comfortable to hold, and as I get older (high torque wrenching less, more arthritis) I'm beginning to change my view on smooth tools. They both have smooth, fine actions. Almost indistinguishable to me. Both of the 1/4"ers are small heads, too. Hard to pick a fav.
To be totally honest I'm really favoring my HF composite ratchet these days. Bigger handle, but grippy soft handle and absolutely great to work with. Not collectible, so, I'm not at all afraid of damaging or losing it.